Red Stag vs Elk Hunting – Similarities & Differences

Introduction to Red Stag and Elk Hunting

Both Red Stag and Elk have storied histories in the hunting world. They are considered prized trophies and at the top of many sportsman’s bucket lists.Their majestic presence and challenging hunts make them sought-after game. They are two of the largest deer species and are revered by many.
Red Stag vs Elk

Overview of Red Stag Hunting

Red Stag are known for their large racks and the incredible areas they inhabit. In fact, Red Stag have the largest antlers in the world relative to their body size.

For many hunters, it is a dream to travel to regions like Europe, New Zealand, and South America/Argentina to harvest one of these magnificent animals. Their elusive nature and the breathtaking landscapes add to the adventure.

Most hunting is done in the fall during the rut, also known as “The Roar”. The Roar must be heard and experienced to fully appreciate its excitement.

Free Range Red Stag
La Pampa, Argentina

Season: March – July

Argentina Flag

  • 6 Nights and 5 Hunting Days
  • One free range Red Stag trophy (no limit on score)
  • Full board lodging – Open Bar
  • One-on-one guiding
Free Range Red Stag
Patagonia, Argentina

Season: March - April

Argentina Flag

  • 5 Nights and 5 Hunting Days
  • One free range Red Stag trophy (no limit on score)
  • Full board lodging – Open Bar
  • One-on-one guiding
  • Hunting License
  • Gun rental available including ammo
Gold Medal Red Stag
Patagonia, Argentina

Season: March – May

Argentina Flag

  • 5 Nights and 5 Hunting Days
  • One Gold Medal Red Stag trophy (400-440 SCI class)
  • Full board lodging – Open Bar
  • One-on-one guiding
  • Hunting License
  • Gun rental available including ammo
Gold Medal Red Stag
La Pampa, Argentina

Season: March – July

Argentina Flag

  • 6 Nigths and 5 Hunting Days
  • One Gold Medal Red Stag trophy (400-420 SCI class)
  • Full board lodging – Open Bar
  • One-on-one guiding
  • Gun rental available including ammo
The Best of Both Worlds!
Red Stag & High Volume Dove Hunting

The Season: March to July

  • 9 nights / 7 Hunting days
  • 4 full days of big game hunting
  • 3 full days of wingshooting
  • Hunting License (game and birds) 
  • Full board lodging – Open Bar

Overview of Elk Hunting

Elk hunting is equally thrilling, with these majestic animals roaming North America's wild terrains. Hunters are drawn to the challenge of tracking and calling elk, often in remote and rugged landscapes.

Elk are known for their impressive antlers and the haunting bugle of bulls during the rut. Many hunters in North America wait all year for the opportunity to chase these animals.


Habitat and Distribution

Red Stag and Elk both have wide ranges they inhabit and can be quite adaptable. Originally, they lived on different continents but in modern times they have been introduced to many areas around the world.

Typical Habitats of Red Stag

Red Stag typically inhabit dense forests, grasslands, and mountainous regions. They thrive in diverse environments, from the Scottish Highlands to the rolling hills of New Zealand and the vast ranges of Argentina. Their adaptability to various habitats makes them widespread.

Most of the places, especially in Argentina, they live in breathtakingly beautiful areas. Hunting in excellent scenery adds to the overall experience. 

Typical Habitats of Elk

Elk are commonly found in North America's mountainous regions, forests, and grasslands. They prefer habitats with ample forage and cover, such as the Rocky Mountains and the Pacific Northwest.

Seasonal migrations often take them to higher elevations in summer and lower valleys in winter. This allows them to access prime feeding areas year-round, which can be critical during harsh winters.

Physical Characteristics and Behavior

Since both are part of the deer family, many characteristics are similar at the very least. Red Stag and Elk both have impressive antlers and size

Distinguishing Features of Red Stag

Red Stag are renowned for their majestic antlers, which can form large, multi-branched racks. Their antlers are the largest in relation to body size in the world, and often have unique structures.

They have a reddish-brown coat that thickens and darkens in winter. In Argentina, these animals can reach especially impressive sizes. Stags (which are the males) are also known for their distinctive, guttural roar during the rutting season. Females are known as hinds.


Distinguishing Features of Elk

Elk are notable for their large size and impressive antlers, which are typically more slender and sweeping than those of Red Stag. Symmetry is more sought after in elk antlers rather than the unique branching. Their coats range from light brown to dark brown, with a distinctive pale rump patch.

Bulls emit a high-pitched bugle during the rut, which is a key characteristic. Many hunters will try to call in bulls during the hunting season.


Behavioral Differences

Red Stag and Elk exhibit different behaviors, especially during the rut. Red Stag are more vocal with their roaring, while Elk rely on their bugle calls.

The mating males of both species will form harems of females.

Hunting Techniques and Strategies

Hunting techniques do have some overlap, and both species present challenges to hunters.

Effective Methods for Red Stag Hunting

Effective Red Stag hunting methods include stalking and calling, often requiring patience and stealth. Hunters need to navigate diverse terrains and use natural cover to get close. During the rut, mimicking the Stag’s roar can attract dominant males.

Effective Methods for Elk Hunting

Elk hunting techniques often involve spot-and-stalk, calling, and ambush strategies. During the rut, calling can be particularly effective, as bulls respond aggressively to bugles. Hunters need to be adept at navigating rugged terrains and understanding Elk behavior.

Seasonal Considerations

Both Red Stag and Elk hunts are influenced by seasonal behaviors. The rutting season, which can vary depending on location, offers the best chances for successful hunts. Understanding migration patterns, the roar/rut beahviors, and seasonal food sources is crucial for planning a successful hunt.

Hunting Weather by Season in Argentina

December 21, 2021

Argentina is one of South America’s top hunting destinations all year round. Some of the most popular types of hunting there include Red Stag, Asian Water Buffalo, Axis Deer, Blackbuck Antelope, Dove, Partridge, and Dorado fishing. There is never a bad time to plan a hunting trip to Argentina, however, it is important to consider…

Gear and Equipment

Due to the regions these animals call home, good gear can be essential to the realization of a hunt. The ability to spot, stalk, move, and stay comfortable can mean the difference between a successful hunt or not.

Recommended Gear for Red Stag Hunting

For Red Stag hunting, recommended gear includes a high-caliber rifle, quality optics, camouflage clothing, and sturdy boots. Hunters should also carry essential survival gear, such as GPS, first-aid kits, and weather-appropriate clothing.

Recommended Gear for Elk Hunting

Elk hunting requires similar gear, with an emphasis on powerful, accurate rifles and high-quality optics. Additionally, hunters should have reliable maps, navigation tools, and sufficient provisions for extended hunts in remote areas.

Trophy Quality and Meat Yield

Antlers and relative size tend to be the main characteristics for determining a trophy of either species. How they are scored and what features are valued can vary slightly between the two.

Both make excellent food sources and can be substituted for just about any beef dish as a healthy, leaner alternative.

Venison on grill with South American Adventure Safari Logo-min

How to Prepare Red Stag After a Hunt

November 14, 2022

The meat from a red stag is venison, which is lean red meat with a rich and clean taste and no gamey flavor. It is high in protein and iron but low in fat and cholesterol, making it recognized by health and fitness professionals.

Evaluating Trophy Red Stag

Trophy Red Stag are evaluated based on antler size, symmetry, and the number of points. In Argentina it is not uncommon to harvest an animal in the 300-320 SCI class for free range and over 400 for the gold medal areas.

A mature Stag with a well-formed, large rack is highly prized. Factors such as body size and condition also play a role in trophy quality.

Evaluating Trophy Elk

Trophy Elk are similarly judged by antler size, with emphasis on tine length and spread. A 5x5 or better is usually considered a very nice animal and entering trophy class  Mature bulls with large, symmetrical antlers are highly sought after. The overall health and age of the animal also contribute to its trophy status.

Meat Yield and Culinary Uses

Both Red Stag and Elk provide high-quality, lean meat. Their venison is prized for its rich flavor and versatility in cooking. Proper field dressing and meat care are essential to preserve the quality of the yield for culinary use.

Why Choose South American Adventure Safaris for Red Stag Hunting (conclusion)

South American Adventure Safaris offers unparalleled experiences for Red Stag hunting. We have several hunting options in different areas giving us the ability to match any client's needs.

With access to prime hunting grounds and expert guides, hunters are ensured a memorable and successful hunt. Their commitment to conservation and sustainable practices makes them a top choice for ethical hunters.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.